If I am comparing managed IT services vs internal IT hiring costs for a Billings business, I do not start by comparing an employee’s salary with an MSP’s monthly invoice.
I start by asking what IT capability the business actually needs.
A competent internal IT hire can easily start around $85,000 per year in salary in the type of hiring scenario I see. Once I account for taxes and benefits, I would plan closer to roughly $110,000 before considering recruiting, training, coverage, and outside specialists. A managed IT provider spreads many of those responsibilities across a team instead of asking one employee to do everything.
That does not automatically make managed IT the right answer for every company. Internal IT, managed IT, and a hybrid approach can all work. The important thing is to compare equivalent capabilities instead of comparing two numbers that buy very different things.
Managed IT Services vs Internal IT Hiring Costs: What Should I Actually Compare?
When I talk with business owners about hiring IT internally, salary is usually the first number on the table.
It is also only part of the cost.
For an internal employee, I would consider:
- Salary
- Employer payroll taxes
- Health and other benefits
- Paid time off
- Recruiting and onboarding
- Training and certifications
- Computer and equipment
- Management and monitoring tools
- Security tools
- Backup and recovery systems
- Additional consultants for problems outside that employee’s expertise
- Coverage when the employee is sick, on vacation, or leaves
The benefit expense is not trivial. In June 2026, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that benefits represented 30 percent of total private-industry employer compensation costs nationally. For businesses with 1 to 49 employees, benefits represented 25.9 percent of compensation. Those figures are not specific to IT employees in Billings, but they illustrate why salary alone understates the cost of adding a full-time employee.
Employers also pay their share of Social Security and Medicare taxes. For 2026, the employer portion is 6.2 percent for Social Security up to the applicable wage base and 1.45 percent for Medicare.
With managed IT, the calculation is different. I would look at the monthly service cost, onboarding or project costs, what tools are included, what is excluded, onsite support, cybersecurity, backup, monitoring, and whether certain projects are billed separately.
That gives me an apples-to-apples comparison.
What Does a Competent Internal IT Hire Really Cost?
In my experience, I would budget upward of $85,000 for the salary of a capable IT employee who can take meaningful ownership of a company’s technology.
My rough planning figure is around $110,000 after employment taxes and benefits.
That is not a published Billings salary statistic, and I would not treat it as one. It is the practical figure I use when thinking through the kind of employee a business would need.
It also does not buy every IT skill the company may require.
That distinction matters.
If I hire one employee for $85,000 and then expect that person to provide help desk support, manage servers, troubleshoot networking, configure firewalls, understand cybersecurity, administer Microsoft 365, maintain backups, support industry-specific applications, handle vendors, plan upgrades, and understand databases, I have not really hired an IT department.
I have hired one person and given that person an IT department’s job description.
Why Is One IT Employee So Difficult to Compare With a Managed IT Team?
There is an old saying that fits IT pretty well: a jack of all trades is usually a master of none.
I may need a firewall specialist one day, a network engineer the next, desktop support that afternoon, and somebody who understands servers or Active Directory after that.
Then I have the technology that is specific to the company.
A veterinary practice might depend on software such as AVImark. Another business might rely heavily on a SQL database. A different company may have unusual networking, cloud, compliance, or line-of-business software requirements.
Cybersecurity adds another layer.
The person who is excellent at helping an employee with Outlook is not automatically the person I want designing firewall rules, investigating a security event, reviewing backup architecture, or making high-level infrastructure decisions.
That does not mean a talented internal employee cannot learn several areas. Many do.
It means I need to be realistic about what I am asking one person to know.
What Happens When the Internal IT Person Takes Vacation or Leaves?
This is one of the simplest differences between the two models.
If I depend on one internal IT employee, that employee eventually gets sick, takes vacation, attends training, or changes jobs.
Then I have to decide who covers IT.
For an MSP, staffing coverage is the provider’s responsibility. The customer should not have to build the provider’s vacation schedule into its business continuity plan.
That team structure is one of the reasons I believe businesses should compare capabilities instead of hourly labor costs.
I am not merely asking, “Who can fix this laptop?”
I am asking, “Who owns this responsibility every week of the year?”
What Can Happen When an Internal Help Desk Has No Senior IT Direction?
One issue I have seen firsthand has nothing to do with whether the help desk employees were intelligent or hardworking.
The problem was that nobody senior was directing the overall technology strategy.
We have worked with companies that already had internal IT help desks. When someone asked the help desk to add a new application or technology, the team often did exactly what was requested.
But nobody was stepping back and asking whether the company already owned something that performed the same function.
At one five-person company, we found three different software products doing essentially the same job.
By consolidating that overlap, we reduced the company’s software expense by more than $1,000 per year.
For a five-person company, that matters.
More importantly, it illustrates a larger point. IT cost is not only the cost of fixing computers. Good IT management should also help a company make better technology decisions.
A help desk solves tickets. Strategic IT leadership should also ask whether the underlying environment makes sense.
Is Managed IT Better Than In-House IT?
I would not make that decision based on the labels.
I would look at the company.
Internal IT can be a good fit when the business strongly values having someone embedded in the company every day, has enough work to justify dedicated staff, has highly specialized internal systems, or wants direct internal ownership of technology strategy.
Managed IT makes more sense to me when the company needs broad technical expertise but cannot economically justify building an entire IT department.
A hybrid arrangement can be better than either extreme.
I work with companies that keep level-one or level-two help desk support internally and escalate more advanced work to us.
I also see the reverse structure at a strategic level. A company may have a CTO or technology leader internally who establishes the direction while an outside team performs much of the technical work.
Another simple arrangement is to have one technically capable person inside the company act as the main point of contact while the managed provider supplies the deeper expertise, direction, and support.
There is no rule saying everything has to be internal or everything has to be outsourced.
When Does Co-Managed IT Make More Sense?
I like co-managed IT when a business already has good internal people and the problem is capacity or specialization rather than basic competence.
For example, an internal employee may know the users, applications, and day-to-day workflow extremely well.
I do not need to replace that knowledge.
Instead, I can support that person when the company needs higher-level networking, cybersecurity, server work, projects, strategic planning, or simply more hands during a busy period.
The arrangement only works if responsibilities are clear.
Who owns the help desk?
Who manages backups?
Who responds to security alerts?
Who administers Microsoft 365?
Who handles vendors?
Who makes purchasing decisions?
Who is responsible if something is missed?
Those questions matter more than whether somebody uses the word “internal” or “managed.”
At What Company Size Should I Hire Internal IT?
I do not think there is a reliable employee-count rule.
Company culture, systems, industry, risk, and workload matter too much.
A 30-person company with simple cloud applications may require less IT attention than a 15-person organization with multiple locations, specialized equipment, regulatory obligations, servers, and complex applications.
That is why I would be cautious with articles that say a company should automatically hire internal IT at 50, 75, or 100 employees.
Those numbers can be useful planning references, but they are not laws.
I would ask a different question:
Do I have enough IT work, of the right type, to justify the cost of the internal team required to perform it properly?
Notice that I said “team,” not simply “employee.”
That is the better comparison.
What Would I Recommend for a 20-Person Billings Company?
For a typical 20-person Billings company, I would usually recommend starting by evaluating a managed service plan rather than immediately hiring one internal IT employee.
My reasoning is straightforward.
At 20 employees, one IT person can end up responsible for everything while still being only one person. If that employee spends the morning troubleshooting user problems, who is reviewing security? If a server issue appears during a project, which priority wins? If the employee goes on vacation, who covers the business?
Building an internal team with enough people to solve those problems can become substantially more expensive.
That does not mean every 20-person company belongs on a fully managed plan.
If the company barely depends on technology, has simple systems, accepts slower response when something goes wrong, and has somebody internally who can safely handle routine administration, full managed IT may be more support than it needs.
I would rather say that clearly than sell a company services it does not need.
How Much Do Managed IT Services Typically Cost?
There is no useful universal price without knowing what is included.
Managed providers may charge per user, per device, a flat monthly rate, or use a combination of those models. Pricing also changes based on cybersecurity requirements, servers, locations, backups, compliance responsibilities, onsite support, and the condition of the existing environment.
That is why I would not compare providers based on the monthly number alone.
Arsenal Dev’s own pricing guide explains that businesses can encounter offers ranging from low per-device pricing to much higher per-user arrangements, with major differences in what those plans actually include. The right comparison depends on business size, industry, security needs, risk tolerance, and technology dependence.
A cheap plan that excludes the services I actually need is not cheaper.
It is incomplete.
What Do Managed IT Services Include?
The answer varies by provider and plan, so I would always ask for a written scope.
A managed IT relationship may include areas such as help desk support, monitoring, device management, software patching, cybersecurity protection, backups, Microsoft 365 administration, vendor coordination, network management, and technology planning.
For example, Arsenal Dev’s managed services information describes help desk support, cybersecurity, network monitoring, device management, patching, backup and disaster recovery, Microsoft 365 management, endpoint protection, technology planning, and vendor coordination as parts of its managed IT approach.
That is why two managed IT proposals with different prices may not be offering the same thing.
What Questions Should I Ask Before Hiring an MSP or Internal IT Employee?
Whether I am hiring a person or a provider, I want to understand who will actually own the important responsibilities.
For an internal candidate, I would ask where that person is strongest and where outside expertise will still be required. I would also plan for vacation coverage, turnover, professional development, tools, cybersecurity, and escalation.
For an MSP, I would want a clear explanation of what the monthly price includes, what costs extra, how support requests are handled, what security responsibilities remain with my company, what happens during an emergency, and how strategic planning works.
I would also ask about tools and licensing.
Who owns the licenses?
Can I leave with my data and documentation?
Which products are included in the monthly price?
Are projects included?
Is onsite work included?
How often will somebody review the overall environment instead of simply closing tickets?
The answers tell me far more than a marketing claim about “unlimited support.”
What Are the Drawbacks of Hiring Internal IT?
Internal IT gives a company direct access to somebody who knows the people and business.
The drawbacks are concentration and cost.
One employee creates a natural single point of dependency. The company also becomes responsible for recruiting, retention, training, management, benefits, coverage, tooling, and outside expertise when something exceeds that employee’s skill set.
With enough scale, those costs can absolutely be justified.
At smaller companies, they are harder to spread across the organization.
What Are the Drawbacks of Managed IT?
Managed IT has tradeoffs too.
An outside provider is not physically sitting inside the company every minute of every day. Quality varies significantly among providers. A poorly designed agreement can leave a business paying extra for projects it assumed were included. A provider can also become frustrating if responsibilities, communication, documentation, or response expectations are unclear.
Outsourcing IT does not mean outsourcing management responsibility.
I still want somebody inside the company who can communicate priorities and hold the provider accountable.
If a company already has a strong technical leader and enough workload for internal staff, I may prefer co-managed IT rather than replacing that team.
How I Would Compare the Two Options
I would write down the capabilities my company actually requires before requesting prices.
That includes routine support, networking, cybersecurity, Microsoft 365, backups, servers, vendor management, specialized applications, strategic planning, projects, onsite requirements, and after-hours needs.
Then I would price what it takes to obtain those capabilities internally.
Not one employee.
The capabilities.
Next, I would ask a managed provider to define which of those responsibilities are included in its agreement and which are not.
Only then am I comparing the same problem.
For many smaller businesses, that exercise makes managed IT attractive because one monthly relationship provides access to a broader team.
For some businesses, it confirms that hiring internally is worth the additional investment.
For others, the answer is obvious: keep the good internal people and bring in an outside team to fill the gaps.
How Arsenal Dev Approaches Managed IT
At Arsenal Dev, I look at managed IT as an ongoing technology partnership rather than a repair service.
Our published managed IT services include areas such as help desk support, cybersecurity, monitoring, device management, software updates, backup and disaster recovery, Microsoft 365 administration, endpoint protection, strategic planning, and vendor coordination.
I also do not believe a company should outsource something simply because we sell it.
If you have strong internal IT and only need advanced support, a co-managed arrangement may make more sense.
If you have straightforward technology requirements and very little support demand, you may not need a full managed service plan yet.
But if your Billings business is relying on one overwhelmed employee, an office manager who became the default IT person, or a collection of outside vendors nobody is coordinating, I think it is worth comparing that arrangement against managed IT.
The useful question is not, “Is an MSP cheaper than an employee?”
It is:
What would it cost me to build the level of IT coverage, expertise, security, and continuity my business actually needs?
If you want to compare your current arrangement with what managed or co-managed IT would look like, I am happy to walk through the numbers and responsibilities with you. You can use the comparison to make your own decision, even if the answer turns out to be keeping IT internal.